Ars Longa Vita Brevis

Prof. Frederick W. Maguire
Prof. Frederick W. Maguire

No Afghanistaning, Please

 

 

The other day I got to thinking about how lucky I was to have known Fred Maguire. 

 

Fred was my first work mentor.  He taught at the Ohio State University Graduate School of Journalism, and I was his teaching assistant from the fall of 1972 to the spring of 1973.   Fresh out of Bowdoin College in Maine, I was eager to learn, but had little else to recommend me.  I never worked on a high school or college newspaper.  My undergraduate degree was in Classics. 

 

I had met an AP reporter in Rome during my junior year abroad.  He took me to the AP Rome bureau.  I thrilled to the brisk purpose, and the 60-baud clack of the teleprinters.  My friend gave me some copy from the AP stringer in Ankara to edit.  It was about an internal crackdown in Turkey, and slugged “The Sledgehammer Technique”.  He complimented me on the rewrite.  I was hooked.  

 

I returned for my last year of college, taught myself how to type, and devoured the New York Times every Sunday.  I read C.L. Sulzberger’s memoir, A Long Row of Candles.  And I applied to graduate schools of journalism.

 

The elders at the OSU School of Journalism not only accepted me into their graduate program, but awarded me a teaching assistantship.  This was a big deal for me, since I was paying the freight. 

 

As I packed my bags in Maine to drive out to OSU, I felt a sense of purpose.  I aspired to work for a great news service, like UPI or AP, and one day become a foreign correspondent.   

 

 

CHOLERIC CELT

 

As a newsman, Frederick W. Maguire had won two national awards, a Nieman Fellowship at Harvard in 1943 and a Sigma Delta Chi national award for courage in journalism in 1944.  These were granted for his expose’ of political corruption in Lowell, Massachusetts, when he was editor and assistant publisher of the Lowell Telegram.  His work resulted in the jailing of the mayor for conspiracy to take bribes and the adoption of a new city charter.

 

“I was called Don Quixote as a term of scorn at that time in Lowell, but I’ve since decided that they’re right,” he said.  “Don Quixote tilted at windmills, I have always tilted at windbags.”

 

Fred Maguire began his career in 1924.  Fresh out of Dartmouth College, he became a cub reporter for the Brooklyn Times, a paper once edited by Walt Whitman.  For the next 23 years, his was a carol of journalistic occupations, with a dash of public relations:  The Portland (Maine) Press Herald; the Brooklyn Eagle, the Lowell (Massachusetts) Telegram, the Louisville Courier-Journal and Times; PM (New York); the Cincinnati Enquirer; the Boston Globe; CBS, the International News Service; the State of Maine Development Commission; Paramount Publics (which owned over 500 theaters), and the National Foundation for Infantile Paralysis.  Then, in 1947, in his words, he “took the tonsure”, and went on campus, starting his teaching career at Michigan State.  He moved in 1949 to Ohio State, where he remained until retiring in June 1973. 

 

It was my good fortune to be with Fred in his final year.  Having lived and worked many years in New England himself, he was delighted to have a teaching assistant from Maine. 

 

A craggy, lean man with a thick mop, Fred smoked nonstop and drank black coffee all day.  His voice was gravel.  He wore his Irish heritage with pride.  Quick to laugh, and quick to rise at perceived injustice, fellow professors dubbed him the Choleric Celt.  Fred loved reading and declaiming, denouncing and pronouncing.  Every office visit was the occasion of a performance.  He littered his conversation with scraps of poetry and song.  One of his favorites was this:

 

Life would be less outrageous,

If all the drinks were free,

Good health were contagious,

And old age fit to see.

And if, when we slipped our tether,

We all went out together,

Like rivers to the sea

 

 

PASSIVE PERIPHRASTIC TO BODONI BOLD

 

When I got to the campus in Columbus, Ohio, I was hungry for nuts and bolts, the craft of journalism.  How to copy edit.  How to write headlines.  How to structure a news story.  

 

There was just one problem.  OSU didn’t offer those things for graduate credit.

 

The university assumed, naturally enough, that one had already picked up such basics at the undergraduate level.  But I hadn’t.  I knew about ablative absolutes and chiasmus.  I knew a passive periphrastic was really just a gerundive of obligation (Carthago delenda est).  But I didn’t know about news style, burying the lead, or Bodoni Bold. 

 

The graduate courses I was expected to take were heavy on social science research, polling methods, and the like.  Not how to write and edit. 

 

Fred was unfazed.   He knew that OSU had immense resources.  There was ample scope to be creative.  Together, we cooked up a proposal for a special small-format graduate-level seminar, which he shepherded, to cover the craft of journalism.  I read Newsman’s English, by Sunday Times editor Harold Evans.  I studied every word of Writing for Newspapers and News Services, by Warren J. Brier and Howard C. Heyn.  I pored over News Editing, by Bruce Westley.     

 

I enrolled in a course on international journalism with Professor Paul Underwood, a former New York Times correspondent in Belgrade.  What I remember best was listening to Underwood’s rich store of anecdote about reporting in the Balkans and Eastern Europe

 

I studied Serbo-Croatian with Professor Kenneth Naylor.  I learned East European history from Professor Carol Rogel, for whom I wrote a long essay on “Freedom of the Press and Expression in Post-War Yugoslavia”.

 

But the most creative twist was conjuring up, with Fred’s help, an independent study with the OSU Speech Department.  For this I prepared and presented the daily WOSU-FM mid-afternoon news summary.  I reviewed the UPI audio feed, selected cuts, and wrote lead-ins for them.  I picked and prioritized among national, international, and local news items.   The Watergate break-in had occurred in June 1972, and pressure was building on the Nixon White House during my time at OSU, so I used a quite a few cuts from UPI’s Pye Chamberlain in Washington. 

 

I learned very quickly that a 30-second audio spot is twice as useful as a 45-second spot for broadcast editors trying to cram as much as possible into a hard ten-minute format.  

 

Best of all, when the package was complete, I got to voice it on the air.   

 

At 2:59 I was in place at the studio, headphones on, the big microphone looming in front of me.  The second hand of the clock swept to the top of the hour.  The “On the Air” light blinked on.    

 

“Good afternoon,” I said.  “It’s three o’clock, time for WOSU’s mid-afternoon edition of the news.  This is David Pearce reporting.” 

 

Hog heaven.  

 

I still have the tape of my final broadcast.

 

 

ON SUPPOSITORIES AND AFGHANISTANING

 

I took the required social science classes, and in fact learned a good bit about communications theory, sampling and polling methods.

 

One of my tasks as a graduate teaching assistant was to help Fred grade class papers.  He taught a course on news writing, and one of his favorite devices was to introduce subject-matter experts to the class from other parts of the university.  The expert would speak on his or her specialty, and answer questions.  The students would then write the event up as a news story. 

 

One day Fred introduced a colleague named John Randall who was an expert on the Middle East.  Randall gave his talk, the students wrote their stories, and I lugged a stack of papers home.   I was bent over the kitchen table, reading and grading, when I came across this lead:

 

  COLUMBUS, Ohio — Middle East expert John Randall said yesterday that the region is of great strategic importance because of its oil suppositories.

 

I circled the word “suppositories” and scribbled “look this up in the dictionary”.  I don’t remember what grade I gave the paper, but it was not an A. 

 

As part of its public outreach, the journalism school helped regional newspapers and press associations with professional development.  It was thus no surprise that Fred, a prize-winning editorialist, was asked to help judge a contest among regional Tennessee newspapers for best editorial writing.  He enlisted my help in reviewing submissions.

 

Before handing me the entries, however, he cast an appraising eye my way.   Fred was aware that I aspired to be a foreign correspondent.  But he wanted to be sure I understood the fundamental importance of local news. 

 

“David,” he said, “Remember, people care about what’s happening at home.  Writing editorials about foreign issues is avoiding the subject.  It’s called ’Afghanistaning’”. 

 

I wrote essays for my master’s exam in journalism on the First Amendment (concluding “we have an administration with little respect for the spirit or letter of the law, and certainly little respect for the people.”); and the Yugoslav press (“The barometer of press freedom in Yugoslavia is the flexibility of the party line…if Tito is intent on unity, it is not likely that he will be tolerating much backtalk from the press”).  I also did a sight translation from Serbo-Croatian of a news article about American pacifists meeting with U.S. prisoners of war in Hanoi. 

 

Fred’s last good turn was to help me get a job in the summer of 1973 at the Associated Press bureau in Columbus, Ohio.  He wrote a strong letter of recommendation to the deputy AP bureau manager, whom he knew, seconded by Professor Underwood.  I received a copy of “Your AP”, an in-house booklet outlining the history and organization of the Associated Press.  I also was given my very own copy of the news editor’s bible, The Associated Press Stylebook.

 

I was off.

 

 

 

TYPEWRITERS AND TELETYPE

 

From AP in Columbus, Ohio, I went to the Rome Daily American in Italy.  UPI hired me away from there, sending me to its Brussels Europe-Middle East-Africa headquarters, and on to cover revolution in Lisbon and civil war in Beirut.  After UPI came the Washington Post Foreign and Metro desks (my Metro Editor boss was Bob Woodward).  After the Post, I was a writer-editor at the book division of the National Geographic Society (and traveled to China just as it started to open up).  Then, while at the National Geographic, I passed the Foreign Service exam.

 

In the first week of January 1982, I signed up with the U.S. Department of State, serving at Foreign Service posts in Riyadh, Tunis, Kuwait, Taif (Saudi Arabia), Dubai, Damascus, Baghdad, Jerusalem, Rome, Algiers, Kabul, and Athens.  Plus four hardship tours in Washington. 

 

After 34 years and 10 months, I left government service in November 2016.

 

So why hark back 46 years to OSU and Fred Maguire? 

 

 

DEATH, REBIRTH, AND AD REVENUES

 

I was reflecting on how the way we receive and process information has changed since I left OSU.   Fred came to mind because he was in many ways the polar opposite of what passes for journalism today.

 

When I started at AP in the summer of 1973, computers were beginning to make an appearance on the broadcast side, but we still worked mainly on typewriters.  No email, no cell phones, no Internet.  Newspapers were set in hot lead.  News photographers and TV cameramen shot film. 

 

In the cycle of technological death and rebirth, the evening television news killed afternoon newspapers.  Cable news, in turn, destroyed the dominance of the networks, especially after the Gulf War of 1990-91, when CNN introduced 24/7 news coverage.   Tectonic shifts in ad revenues accompanied these changes.  This affected the profitability of the broadcast networks, weekly news magazines, and major newspapers.  When they cut back, the first thing to go was costly foreign news bureaus. 

 

If the business of journalism was profoundly affected by technological change, so too was the business of government.  When I joined the Foreign Service in 1982, we wrote cables on typewriters with multi-sheet carbon paper.  If a mistake was made, the whole page had to be retyped.  There were even fewer computers in government than in journalism, and they were more primitive.    

 

Many diplomats could not type, and drafted cables by dictation or writing them out long hand on yellow legal pads.  Professional Foreign Service secretaries would put them in the right format for the embassy communications center.  There, technicians would punch a perforated paper tape, just as wire service teletype operators did, to be sent via leased telephone lines through the local PTT, or directly via HF radio transmission.  

 

The advent, in rapid succession, of optical character readers, computer word processing, email, cell phones, the Internet and social media applications dramatically sped up the volume of information available to both publics and governments.  That, in turn, revolutionized the way people and governments received and processed information, and how they interacted with each other. 

 

While the advances in technology brought much good, more and quicker did not always mean progress.   

 

Hierarchies were flattened.  Pressure on decisionmakers increased.  Time for analysis and deliberation was compressed.  The need for confidentiality meant classified messages remained important, but less and less was done by cable, and more and more by email.  The public messaging aspect of policy work took on more importance than ever. 

 

 

Above, an example of marked-up copy, from Bruce Westley’s News Editing

 

 

GATEKEEPERS:  UBI SUNT?

 

The first sentence in the 1972 edition of Westley’s News Editing instructed the neophyte editor thus: “In any medium of communication, someone serves as a final ‘gatekeeper’, a key decisionmaker who is responsible for determining what will and what will not be communicated, and sees to it that what goes out is in a finished condition.  The gatekeepers on the daily newspaper are the news editor and copy editors who work under his supervision.” 

 

Westley noted that copy editing was basic to mass communications.  “The writer doesn’t exist whose work cannot be improved by the constructive vigilance of an editor,” he wrote.  “The individual copy editor has many things in mind as he works on a story.  He must eliminate errors of spelling, grammar, sentence structure, style, taste, fact, and organization.  He must guard against unwarranted reportorial bias, verbosity, repetition, wearisome detail, overlooked facts, incongruities, advertising in disguise, libel, lottery, hoaxes, old news, ax grinding, and duplication.”

 

Copy editing.

 

This was what I was so keen to learn in the fall of 1972 when I first showed up at Fred’s office.  The real craft of journalism and journalistic writing. 

 

Quaint notion.  The editor as a guardian of taste?  Gatekeepers? 

 

Ubi sunt? 

 

The gates are wide open, on social media especially, to crude language, pornography, insults, taunts. and general bad manners.  Overlooked facts are just overlooked.  Ax grinding is frequently the main point of the editorial engagement.    

 

About 30 years ago, Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan remarked, “Everybody is entitled to their own opinions, but not their own facts.” 

 

Fine words, but as a practical matter, this is no longer the case.  Just as there are no standards, so too there are no facts. 

 

With comparatively few exceptions, editorial processes seem to focus more on magnifying impact and increasing audience share rather than on dispassionate presentation of news.  Repetition and wearisome detail are the coin of the realm.  Panels of experts on cable news networks force-feed us circular discussions of breaking news that is not breaking, a relentless pitter-patter of conflated news and opinion.   

 

Fred would hate it. 

 

He believed in gatekeepers, standards, careful copy editing, and assiduous separation of news reporting and editorializing. 

 

No Afghanistaning.

 

And that’s why I was thinking the other day of how lucky I was to have started my working career with him.  A crusading local newspaper editor who made his town a better place.  A Choleric Celt.  Irascible.  Indignant.  Decent.  Fair.  Insistent on high editorial standards.  

 

A man for others.  A mentor who made a difference.  A tilter at windbags.  

 

Thank you, Fred.

 

nnnn

 

 

#journalism #OSU #graduateschool #OhioState #OhioStateUniversity #editing #writing #editors #editorials #writers #journalists #reporters #socialmedia #gatekeepers #poetry #DonQuixote #windmills #standards #ethics #Nieman #Harvard #SigmaDeltaChi #Maine #Dartmouth #Lowell #Massachusetts #corruption #mayor #crusading #AP #UPI #Columbus #Ohio #Afghanistan #MiddleEast #dedication #technology #Irish #Celt

For links to my Etsy shop (free shipping in U.S.), social media handles, and assorted press interviews, please see https://linktr.ee/ddpearcefineart


Comments


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post