Ars Longa Vita Brevis

Kaak Seller, Jaffa, circa 1940
Annals of a Middle East Treat
One of the things I most enjoy is creating paintings that tell a story. Among my favorite subjects are historical subjects from the Middle East, where I spent much of my 35-year Foreign Service career. My latest painting is one of these. In the past I have produced historical interpretations from a circa 1900 stereo card view of the Damascus Gate in Jerusalem and of a water carrier in Old Kuwait from a grainy black and white photo I found in H.R.P. Dixon's book The Arab of the Desert. The inspiration for this painting of Old Jaffa came from a black and white photo in the G. Eric and Edith Matson photographic ollection in The Library of Congress. The photo that launched me is titled "Market Place, Jaffa". The Library catalog lists its date of creation as "between 1940 and 1946". The call number is LC-M33- 12979 [P&P].
Challenges and Changes
This particular Jaffa photo -- one of many in the Matson collection -- captured my imagination for several reasons.
First, there was the light. The contrasts were dramatic and I knew it would be a major challenge to get the values right, i.e. to capture both the blinding lights of midday glare and the correspondingly deep darks in the shadows rimming the square and anchoring the figures.
Second, there would be much to do reordering the scene, removing extraneous detail and simplifying and reshaping buildings, shops and awnings. The mosque would have to be lighter in value than the closer buildings and recede in the distance. Otherwise, it would compete for attention with the vendor in the foreground, whom I planned to be the star of the show. Middle-distance structures would gradate from light to dark. Foreground structures would need dark, but not black, values. All colors would be imagined and had to be in harmony.
Since the painting would be considerably larger than the photograph, and photographs tend to distort perspective, multiple adjustments in composition were required. Wires, antennas, and other detail would be left out. The slope of the rooflines and the height of the figures would be altered. I would repopulate the scene with my own set of marketgoers in proper perspective. In the foreground, for example, I had to make the man strolling left taller than he appeared in the photo for the perspective to work. All this front-end engineering took multiple drawings and value sketches before I ever picked up a brush.
Third, in addition to the appeal of challenges in light and composition, I had become interested in the subject matter while doing an earlier painting of the Old Jaffa marketplace. Jaffa was a key junction in the Ottoman era, with roads converging on its marketplace from Nablus to the north, Jerusalem to the east and Gaza to the south. Using historical photos and maps, I sought in that first piece to depict the area as it might have looked in the late 1800s when Tel Aviv did not yet exist and Jaffa was the main port of entry to Ottoman Palestine. "Old Jaffa, Marketplace" sold fairly quickly and has since proven to be the most popular print in my Etsy shop.
The Library of Congress shot captures this same spot, Jaffa's main market square, but some 40 years later and from the opposite perspective. The first painting had been a south to north view; this one would be from the northeast looking south. The first piece had been an aerial overview while the second would be close up and ground level.
Star of Show: The Kaak Vendor
The fourth, and decisive, factor in deciding to paint this scene was the kaak vendor in the right foreground. Kaak is a delicious ring-shaped bread coated with flavorful sesame seeds and widely sold throughout the Middle East. The scene evoked for me the sights and smells of many walks in the souqs and streets of Syria and Lebanon, where I spent four and three years, respectively. The vendor here bends intently over his little cart piled high with kaak. The midday light reflects off the keffiyeh covering his head and chest. I imagine it is a Friday and he has set up his stand to catch the crowd emerging onto the market area after noontime prayers. At his feet crouches a figure in blue suitcoat and red fez, partially shielding himself from the sun in the shadow of the cart. He seems to have settled in pretty comfortably, so I would guess he is more likely a friend of the vendor than a customer.
Backdrop: The Mahmoudiya Mosque
In the background is the minaret of the Mahmoudiya Mosque, also known as the Great Mosque, or al-Jami'a al-Kabir. Throughout the Islamic world, the main marketplace is invariably adjacent to the main mosque. This urban history makes eminent sense since everyone goes to the mosque and merchants tend to set up shop where the traffic is.
Built in the early 19th century by an Ottoman governor, the Mahmoudiya is Jaffa's largest mosque, a complex of buildings built around three courtyards. Its two domes may be seen in the middle distance, in front of and to the right of the minaret. The row of shops along the right side of the street conceals the exterior walls of the mosque and marks the line of the old Jaffa city wall, torn down in the 19th century to allow for the city's expansion.
Around the turn of the 20th century the center of government, or Serail, moved outside the old walls to the east of the mosque. This would be the area behind the buildings on the middle left of this painting. The large curved structure to the right, in front of the domes and above the shop awnings, is the so-called “Gate of the Governors”, built in the mosque's east wall to facilitate access to it from the new Serail.
For links to my Etsy shop (free shipping in U.S.), social media handles, and assorted press interviews, please see https://linktr.ee/ddpearcefineart
